Welcome to ECCIE - Sign up today!

eatatthewhy · 12-22-2011, 05:28 PM

Hey Guys,
I did a review a few days ago titled Tatianna Stone – The American Geisha
It was not reviewed by staff and I didn't get a reply or a credit. I can see its been busy, but can somebody read the review and send me an approval letter and add my credit on for my account, or tell me if it was rejected for some reason.
Thanks.

urhuckleberry · 12-22-2011, 05:53 PM

Well it looks like you just cut & paste a review template into a new thread. You get no automatic credit if you do that. It is necessary to click on "new review" and use that template. Your ROS was public because you didn't use the proper format. I put the ROS in "private"

Huck

eatatthewhy · 12-26-2011, 05:04 PM

I cut and paste it with all the correct fields because the review was long and I didn't want the server to time out while I entered it. So I am not going to get credit for the review? I will do it your way next time, but the review is posted and deserves credit.

eatatthewhy · 12-27-2011, 06:15 PM

I read all the rules and there is nothing that says that you must use the new form or you will not get credit.
The new feature mostly talks about how a review links to the providers reviews.
The older sticky's mainly talk about having complete information. Since my cut and paste was from your fields it was the same as your form and the review contained all the required information.
If you are not giving credit for a review because it was a cut and paste you need to specify that in your new suggestions, because that is all you do is suggest to use the new format. Their is no requirement to use it or anything stating not using the form will cause no credit to be given for the review.
As for as my ROS was public, I thought all reviews were moderated before submitted in which that could easily be fixed.
Either change the rules or stand by the rules you have. Please point me to the rule that says your new method must be used or no credit. All I saw was a suggestion to use the new forms.
My review is complete and not missing information like a lot of reviews you approve.

Please cut and paste the section of the guidelines that requires someone to use the new method or no credit, and I will shutup.
If you cant do that I deserve credit!

JDNorthface · 12-27-2011, 07:37 PM

Hurry, Huck. I think it's past his bedtime.

Sir Lancelot · 12-27-2011, 08:01 PM

EATW,

First it isn't a new form. It has been the same since the day ECCIE went on-line.

Second, when you fail to use the review button/form the post never shows up for the mods to approve for credit. It is simply too much work for us to copy all that over for you and give credit.

This is not about you - it is the way the system works. So if you want credit, you will have to post it as a new review - not a new thread.

Thanks for your cooperation.

SL

massage4workinggirls · 12-28-2011, 04:35 AM

why can i not find thsi so called new review button on this website. i now have two reviews to file.

eatatthewhy · 12-28-2011, 11:08 AM

And can you tell me the basis for this comment. Is it an inside joke. What is the pertinence to this thread?

Quote:

Originally Posted by JDNorthface

Hurry, Huck. I think it's past his bedtime.

eatatthewhy · 12-28-2011, 11:24 AM

Okay I can repost it and will use the online form next time, but maybe you can add in the sticky's that use of the form is mandatory.
I had a legit reason of not being a fast
Typist and have had the web server time me out and lose my work. I will right the review on my PC and cut and paste into each field on the form and avoid the timeouts and get credit for the review.
Thank you for your assistance and tell the guy that thinks his post is funny sounds like a lid making prank calls he is not funny and needs to growup.
Thanks

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sir Lancelot

EATW,

First it isn't a new form. It has been the same since the day ECCIE went on-line.

Second, when you fail to use the review button/form the post never shows up for the mods to approve for credit. It is simply too much work for us to copy all that over for you and give credit.

This is not about you - it is the way the system works. So if you want credit, you will have to post it as a new review - not a new thread.

Thanks for your cooperation.

SL

Guest022315 · 12-28-2011, 01:02 PM

Eathwhy when your actually doing a review there is no real time limit unless your trying to edit after you hit send. To redue your review is simple copy and paste on to the proper form. Although i have not read it yet i will look for it. I think fellow hobbiest are just poking at you lighten up