Poll - What forum should the Niagara Falls Canada reviews be posted to

[brutusbluto]

Since my efforts to change this did not work, lets see what the membership in upstate New York says on this subject.

What forum should the Niagara Falls Canada reviews be posted to. Poll will close in 15 days.

[elghund]

BB,

I don't go to Canada, or Niagara Falls for that matter.......but if I wanted to, the last place I would think to look would be Toronto......

I would have left well enough alone. Upstate was working for the NF reviews......


elg......

[dearhunter]

Since the primary purpose of a review is to assist the membership in determining whether they want to see the provider, I would thinck Upstate NY.....international boundaries not withstanding.

Have you asked for a separate Niagra Falls Canada Forum?

[offshoredrilling]

I voted Upset NY
even if I'm ok as is if we can have thread linking to reviews

[Guest070916]

Originally Posted by elghund

I would have left well enough alone. Upstate was working for the NF reviews.......

Yup! This fine precedent always worked fine since Day 1 here, bring it back!....

[brutusbluto]

Originally Posted by dearhunter

Have you asked for a separate Niagra Falls Canada Forum?

Yes

http://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=1275929

[Guest072323]

Originally Posted by brutusbluto

Yes

http://www.eccie.net/showthread.php?t=1275929

Thankfully, I don't have access to that secret club.

[dearhunter]

There are conflicting desires in your situation.

The board has a desire on the one hand to give your local membership access to hobby related information (reviews being #1 on that list).

The board has a desire to grow the participation in the Canada section of the board.

The way I see it. Because of the close proximity, Upstate NY will take up all of the oxygen in the room. I would liken it to an attempt to have two separate forums for Kansas City......one in Kansas and one in Missouri. You have to have them together under one area (as was done).

That is just my opinion.

[brutusbluto]

agree. There could be a separate forum for the Niagara Falls Canada reviews, there are many of them.

[offshoredrilling]

Originally Posted by dearhunter

There are conflicting desires in your situation.

The board has a desire on the one hand to give your local membership access to hobby related information (reviews being #1 on that list).

The board has a desire to grow the participation in the Canada section of the board.

The way I see it. Because of the close proximity, Upstate NY will take up all of the oxygen in the room. I would liken it to an attempt to have two separate forums for Kansas City......one in Kansas and one in Missouri. You have to have them together under one area (as was done).

That is just my opinion.

A Niagara falls or a Niagara falls Canada would be OK by me. I still rather as it was posting them in Upset NY. So I have fewer areas to suck up oxygen. MMM a new area I would have to drop reading Houston sandbox maybe.

[moneytalksny]

A "computer genius" could do what's do on eBay. A single review could be linked or posted to multiple relevant forums. In a manner similar to posting goods in multiple eBay categories. I vote for keeping the nearby Canadian reviews in the upstate NY region and one could argue that the same could be done for a few of the PA gems that are just a few hours south.

ECCIE could also introduce an escort app / functionality, that shows all providers within an XXX mile radius...

MTny

[Plastic Man]

anyone want to guess ...where the single ...toronto vote ...came from

[JohnnyCap]

Originally Posted by dearhunter

There are conflicting desires in your situation.

The board has a desire on the one hand to give your local membership access to hobby related information (reviews being #1 on that list).

The board has a desire to grow the participation in the Canada section of the board.

The way I see it. Because of the close proximity, Upstate NY will take up all of the oxygen in the room. I would liken it to an attempt to have two separate forums for Kansas City......one in Kansas and one in Missouri. You have to have them together under one area (as was done).

That is just my opinion.

I wonder if there were to be a Niagara, Ontario or "Lower Ontario" forum, if it would get more for exposure to ladies in that area. Do any Canadians come here to hobby, I would doubt it, but what do eccie ladies say?

Originally Posted by Plastic Man

anyone want to guess ...where the single ...toronto vote ...came from

You? I didn't vote yet.

[offshoredrilling]

Originally Posted by moneytalksny

A "computer genius" could do what's do on eBay. A single review could be linked or posted to multiple relevant forums. In a manner similar to posting goods in multiple eBay categories. I vote for keeping the nearby Canadian reviews in the upstate NY region and one could argue that the same could be done for a few of the PA gems that are just a few hours south.

ECCIE could also introduce an escort app / functionality, that shows all providers within an XXX mile radius...

MTny

shhhhhhhhh before the outsiders of Upset NY find out about the few PA reviews posted in Upset NY. We don't want a repeat of all of this at this time.
^^^iggy don't read this post please ^^^
but you can read below
btw iggy how is the mass reviews posted in A/HV going??

[iggy]

Mods Typically Applying the rules to suit their own benefit.

Let a member bend a rule and the same Mods will jump all over them !!


OSD if you would read the review thread , I also stated it belongs in mass.